Przejdź do treści

Nowość

Skysat dostarcza swoje produkty na terenie całej Unii Europejskiej 🇪🇺

Article expert

Hydraulic vs electromechanical ram — which choice for your sailboat?

The essential in 30 seconds

  • ≤ 12 m / 7.5 t : linear electromechanical ram is sufficient. Simple, low maintenance, material cost €1,500-2,200. Brands: Garmin GHP 12 Type 1, Raymarine Type 1, Lecomble & Schmitt MK1.
  • 12-15 m / 7.5-13.5 t : Type 2 electromechanical still works for cruising, hydraulic recommended in rough seas and offshore. Material cost €2,200-3,500.
  • ≥ 15 m / 13.5 t or racing : hydraulic is mandatory. Power, speed, reversibility are essential. Brands: B&G hydraulic T1, T2, Lecomble & Schmitt MK2/MK3, Simrad DD15.
  • 3 key criteria to decide: thrust force (minimum 1,000 N/t displacement), rudder speed (3-5 s/° in cruising, < 2 s/° in racing), reversibility helm ↔ autopilot (hydraulic wins).
  • Full refit budget: electromechanical €4,000-6,500 VAT installed (ram + computer + sensors + labor), hydraulic €6,500-12,000 VAT.

The rudder ram is the force component of the autopilot. It converts an electrical signal into rudder movement. Two technology families coexist: electromechanical (electric motor + worm screw) and hydraulic (pump + cylinder). Choosing one or the other determines 10 years of use, the refit budget, and the autopilot's relevance in conditions.

If you are looking for maintenance of your existing ram, see our article on rudder ram maintenance. For the complete choice of autopilot (ram + computer + sensors), see B&G vs Raymarine autopilot for 40-50 ft sailboats. This article is dedicated solely to the choice of ram technology.


The two families: electromechanical vs hydraulic

Linear electromechanical

An electric motor turns a worm screw that pushes or pulls a rod. The rod is mechanically connected to the rudder quadrant. Everything is integrated into a single housing: ram = finished product, installed and forgotten.

  • Brands on Skysat: Garmin GHP 12 Type 1 (€1,916), Type 2 (€2,191), Raymarine Type 1/2/3, Lecomble & Schmitt MK1/MK2/MK3 (currently not distributed by Skysat).
  • Typical range: sailboats 8-15 m, up to 13.5 t displacement, rod stroke 250-350 mm.
  • Force: 7.5-13.5 kN depending on model.

Hydraulic

An electric pump pressurizes oil in a cylinder attached to the rudder quadrant. The pump can be separate from the cylinder (typical for small-medium sailboats) or integrated into a direct drive system (yacht ≥ 50 ft, racing).

Technical comparison: 6 criteria that determine the choice

1. Thrust force

Workshop rule of thumb: 1,000 N per ton of displacement at full load in standard cruising. For offshore racing or heavy offshore cruising, increase to 1,500 N/t.

  • 8 t cruising sailboat → minimum 8 kN ram → Type 1 electromechanical or light hydraulic.
  • 14 t offshore cruising sailboat → 14 kN ram → Type 3 electromechanical or T2 hydraulic.
  • 20 t racing sailboat → 30 kN ram → large-stroke hydraulic (DD15, MK3+).

2. Rudder speed (degrees per second)

The speed at which the ram can correct a heading deviation. Critical in rough seas and racing.

  • Electromechanical typical: 3-6 s for hard-over to hard-over (35° each side).
  • Hydraulic typical: 2-4 s for hard-over to hard-over.
  • Racing direct drive hydraulic (Simrad DD15, Lewmar GP): 1-2 s for hard-over to hard-over.

3. Electrical consumption

#1 or #2 consumer on the 24 h energy balance (see our article on lithium bank sizing).

  • Electromechanical at rest: 0.1 A (just logic power).
  • Electromechanical in correction: 1-3 A (Type 1) to 3-6 A (Type 3).
  • Hydraulic at rest: 0.2-0.5 A (stand-by pump).
  • Hydraulic in correction: 3-8 A peak, but shorter cycles.

Over 24 h in rough seas, total consumption is broadly equivalent between the two technologies — hydraulic consumes more at peak but cycles faster, so for less time.

4. Reversibility (helm ↔ autopilot ↔ helm transition)

The ram's ability to free the rudder when the autopilot is disengaged.

  • Linear electromechanical: the worm screw mechanically locks the rudder even with autopilot off. "Braking" sensation for the helm, who must push against the internal resistance of the ram. Major drawback in racing and short-handed sailing.
  • Hydraulic with automatic bypass: autopilot off = open valves = 100% free rudder. The helm resumes without any resistance. This is the criterion that tips 90% of racing programs toward hydraulics.

5. Maintenance and lifespan

No major difference if installation is correct. See our rudder ram maintenance guide.

  • Electromechanical: 1 greasing of shafts + rod ends per season, bronze bushings check every 500 h, typical lifespan 10-15 years.
  • Hydraulic: annual oil level and quality check, drain every 5 years, typical lifespan 12-18 years.
  • Racing direct drive hydraulic: more precise maintenance (seals, pressure, solenoid valve), lifespan 8-12 years in intensive racing use.

6. Footprint and installation

  • Electromechanical: 1 compact housing to mount between frame and rudder quadrant. Installation in 4-8 h in the workshop.
  • Hydraulic: 2 components (pump + cylinder) connected by high-pressure hoses. Installation 8-16 h in the workshop (hose runs + system bleeding).
  • Racing direct drive hydraulic: complex integration on rudder shaft, installation 16-32 h.

Linear electromechanical ram — details and brands

The historical technology for sailboat pleasure craft since the 1980s. Widely adopted because it is the simplest product to integrate in a refit.

Garmin GHP 12 (linear rams)

Skysat distributes the Type 1 (€1,916) for sailboats ≤ 11 m / 7.5 t and the Type 2 (€2,191) for sailboats 11-15 m / 7.5-13.5 t. The ram is controlled via a Reactor 40 computer and a GHC 50 display.

Raymarine Type 1/2/3

Historical Raymarine Evolution range. Type 1 ≤ 11 m, Type 2 11-15 m, Type 3 15-22 m. Compatible with Raymarine EV-100/EV-200/EV-400 computer. Skysat distributes the ACU computer and Raymarine accessories; the ram itself may sometimes be ordered as a special order.

Lecomble & Schmitt MK1/MK2/MK3

French historical manufacturer (Vendée). Very common on new Bénéteau/Jeanneau sailboats. Rod stroke 250 mm (MK1), 300 mm (MK2), 350 mm (MK3). Force 7.5 kN to 22 kN. Skysat does not distribute these as standard but can source them on refit project request.

Hydraulic ram — details and brands

Mandatory technology beyond 15 m, highly recommended for offshore racing from 10 m. Pump + cylinder + bypass + pressure gauge architecture.

B&G hydraulic T1/T2

Skysat distributes the B&G T1 12V (€1,700) and T2 24V (€2,070). Compatible with NAC-3 Navico computer (€1,649). For sailboats 11-18 m, comfortable offshore cruising, and Category B/C racing.

Simrad DD15 (Direct Drive 15 kN)

The DD15 (€1,962) is a direct drive hydraulic power unit for sailboats 15-22 m racing/large cruising. Force 15 kN, hard-over to hard-over speed 1-2 s. Immediate reversibility. Integration requires a dedicated rudder shaft.

Garmin SmartPump v2

The SmartPump v2 (€2,899) hydraulic pump is compatible with existing hydraulic systems (third-party cylinders). Controlled by the Garmin Reactor 40 hydraulic GHC 50 computer (€2,080). Good choice for boats already equipped with an original hydraulic cylinder (e.g., Bénéteau Yacht line yachts).

Lecomble & Schmitt hydraulic MK1/MK2/MK3

Separate pumps and cylinders, hydraulic equivalents of the L&S electromechanical range. Widely used in French offshore racing (IMOCA, Class40). Available on special order via Skysat.

Comparison table by size and program

Sailboat Program Recommended tech Reference type Ram force VAT installed budget
≤ 10 m / 5 t Weekend coastal Electromechanical Garmin Type 1, Raymarine Type 1, L&S MK1 5-8 kN €3,500-4,500
10-12 m / 5-7.5 t Coastal + 1-2 weeks summer Electromechanical Type 1 Garmin Type 1 (€1,916) + Reactor 40 7.5 kN €4,000-5,500
11-13 m / 7.5-10 t Offshore cruising Electromechanical Type 2 OR light hydraulic Garmin Type 2 (€2,191) OR B&G T1 (€1,700) + NAC-3 10-13 kN €5,500-7,500
13-15 m / 10-13.5 t Offshore + transatlantic Hydraulic B&G T2 24V (€2,070) + NAC-3 13.5 kN €7,000-9,500
15-18 m / 13.5-18 t Offshore comfort Hydraulic T2/T3 L&S MK2 hydraulic + NAC-3 15-18 kN €8,500-12,000
15-22 m / 13.5-22 t Offshore racing IMOCA/Class40 Direct drive hydraulic Simrad DD15 (€1,962) + NAC-3 + Madintec 15-22 kN €12,000-18,000
≥ 20 m yacht Yacht configured with CZone External pump hydraulic + third-party cylinder Garmin SmartPump v2 + Reactor 40 GHC 50 15-22 kN €10,000-15,000
Garmin GHP 12 Type 1 — linear electromechanical ram for sailboat
Garmin GHP 12 Type 1 — linear electromechanical ram for sailboat

Numerical examples: 35 / 45 / 55 ft sailboat

35 ft sailboat (10.5 m) / 6.5 t — coastal cruising and 2 weeks offshore per year

45 ft sailboat (13.5 m) / 11 t — offshore cruising + 1 transatlantic every 5 years

55 ft sailboat (16.8 m) / 16 t — offshore racing + crewed transatlantic

5 common mistakes in choosing

Ram choice mistakes — observed in Skysat workshop

  1. Undersizing due to optimism. The sailboat manufacturer lists 7.5 t displacement, so a Type 1 is chosen. Except the boat sails with 800 L of water + fuel + crew + 200 kg of gear = 9.5 t real displacement. The Type 1 labors, overheats, and eventually fails. Always size based on actual sailing displacement, not manufacturer specs.
  2. Choosing electromechanical to "save money" on a 15+ m offshore sailboat. Type 3 electromechanical costs ~€1,000 less than T2 hydraulic. Except in rough seas at 25 knots, the electromechanical saturates, the autopilot disengages, and it's hand-steering 18 h/day. The real "savings" are negative.
  3. Hydraulic without automatic bypass. If the hydraulic system lacks automatic bypass valves (as in some old kits), the rudder remains locked even with autopilot off. The helm struggles, the crew complains. Always verify the presence of bypass at purchase.
  4. Choosing an incompatible brand with the existing ecosystem. The boat has a Raymarine Axiom chartplotter. The owner buys a Garmin Reactor 40 autopilot to save money. Result: no autopilot control from the Axiom, Garmin remote required at the cockpit, two parallel ecosystems. Choose an autopilot from the same brand as the main chartplotter — or an open system like Madintec that works with everything.
  5. Undersized hydraulic pump relative to the cylinder. A 15 kN cylinder with an undersized pump = slow correction, the autopilot lags, oscillations. Always pair pump and cylinder from the same manufacturer or validated together by the installer.

FAQ — Choosing your sailboat ram

Can an existing electromechanical system be converted to hydraulic?

Yes, but installation is heavy: new hydraulic cylinder, new pump, high-pressure hose runs, system bleeding, possible modification of the rudder quadrant. Allow 16-24 h workshop labor + €2,500-4,000 material depending on configuration. Only relevant if the boat's program evolves significantly (cruising → racing, or upgrade from coastal to offshore after insufficient experience).

My sailboat already has a Lecomble & Schmitt ram, can I control it with a Garmin or B&G computer?

Yes, the L&S ram is mechanical (or hydraulic) — it accepts any compatible control signal. The computer + rudder angle sensor + compass combination can come from any ecosystem. Verify the electrical interface of the existing L&S (voltage, max current, position feedback type) and adapt the computer accordingly. The Madintec MAD Controller is designed to control almost any ram on the market.

What is the difference between reversible and non-reversible hydraulic?

Reversible hydraulic = double-direction pump (can pull or push the cylinder), requires bypass valves to free the rudder. Non-reversible hydraulic = single-direction pump, the rudder is mechanically linked pump-cylinder when autopilot is off (permanent brake). Always prefer reversible with automatic bypass for safety and helm comfort. All modern B&G/Garmin/Raymarine systems are reversible by default.

Dry or wet hydraulic pump?

Dry pump in 99% of cases. The pump is mounted in a ventilated technical locker near the cylinder. Wet pump (immersed in the oil reservoir) exists on some old systems but requires a sealed reservoir and complete disassembly for maintenance. If refitting, switch to a modern dry pump.

Rudder ram vs tiller quadrant: compatible?

Yes in almost all pleasure craft configurations. The ram drives the rudder quadrant (the part that transmits the tiller rotation to the rudder) via a link arm. Compatibility depends on the quadrant's rotation angle (typically 70° total, ±35° each side), the ram's stroke, and available space. Always verify with a workshop measurement on site before purchase.

Should a backup ram be installed for offshore sailing?

Not a backup ram, but a backup strategy: emergency tiller / windvane (Aries, Hydrovane, Windpilot) for sail, or drogue / demountable tiller for power. The electric ram is a sensitive system — on a transatlantic, always have at least a manual tiller control cable with the ability to disconnect the ram from the quadrant (typical demountable pin). See our rudder ram maintenance guide for signs of impending failure.

What wiring should be installed between computer and ram?

Wire gauge calculated on max current of the ram + 30% margin. Electromechanical Type 1 (5-10 A): 2 × 4 mm² cable for 3-5 m runs. Type 2-3 (10-15 A): 2 × 6 mm². Hydraulic pump (8-15 A peak): minimum 2 × 6 mm², up to 2 × 10 mm² for powerful pumps. Always protect with a fuse calibrated to the ram's nominal current (not peak) + 50%, accessible from the dashboard for quick reset in case of incident.

Skysat distributes B&G, Garmin, Raymarine, Navico, Madintec, and Simrad. This article reflects our experience installing autopilots on more than 120 sailboats between 2018 and 2026, in cruising and offshore racing. 2026 VAT prices are indicative distributor prices, excluding specific wiring and mechanical adaptation to the existing rudder quadrant.

Poprzedni artykuł Następny artykuł

Dodaj komentarz